Juveniles: detention.
What it does: (1) Existing law requires a court to determine whether a minor in custody will be released from, or detained in, custody, considering, among other things, whether it is a matter of immediate and urgent necessity for the protection of the minor or reasonably necessary for the protection of the person or property of another and whether continuance in the home is contrary to the minor’s welfare. This bill would prohibit the court from ordering that a minor be detained in a juvenile hall unless it makes a finding that a less restrictive alternative to detention in the juvenile hall is unsuitable. (official summary)
Question before the chamber: SB 1009 Becker Senate Third Reading By Harabedian
The tally
Yes 43 · No 20 · Not voting 16
Bar: green = yes, brown = no, striped = not voting.
| Party | Yes | No | Not voting |
|---|---|---|---|
| Democrats | 43 | 1 | 16 |
| Republicans | 0 | 19 | 0 |
Most Democrats voted yes; most Republicans voted no. 1 member voted against their party’s majority.
Voted against their party’s majority
The full roll (79)
Yes 43
- Alex LeeD24
- Ash KalraD25
- Buffy WicksD14
- Catherine StefaniD19
- Cecilia Aguiar-CurryD4
- Celeste RodriguezD43
- Chris RogersD2
- Chris WardD78
- Corey JacksonD60
- Cottie Petrie-NorrisD73
- Damon ConnollyD12
- Dawn AddisD30
- Diane PapanD21
- Gail PellerinD28
- Gregg HartD37
- Isaac BryanD55
- Jacqui IrwinD42
- Jesse GabrielD46
- Jessica CalozaD52
- Joaquin ArambulaD31
- John HarabedianD41
- Josh LowenthalD69
- LaShae Sharp-CollinsD79
- Liz OrtegaD20
- Lori WilsonD11
- Maggy KrellD6
- Marc BermanD23
- Mark GonzálezD54
- Matt HaneyD17
- Mia BontaD18
- Mike FongD49
- Mike GipsonD65
- Nick SchultzD44
- Patrick AhrensD26
- Rebecca Bauer-KahanD16
- Rick ZburD51
- Robert GarciaD50
- Robert RivasD29
- Sade ElhawaryD57
- Sharon Quirk-SilvaD67
- Steve BennettD38
- Tasha BoernerD77
- Tina McKinnorD61
No 20
- Ali MacedoR33
- Anamarie Avila FariasD15
- Carl DeMaioR75
- David TangipaR8
- Diane DixonR72
- Greg WallisR47
- Heath FloraR9
- Heather HadwickR1
- Jeff GonzalezR36
- Joe PattersonR5
- Joshua HooverR7
- Juan AlanisR22
- Kate SanchezR71
- Laurie DaviesR74
- Leticia CastilloR58
- Natasha JohnsonR63
- Phillip ChenR59
- Stan EllisR32
- Tom LackeyR34
- Tri TaR70
Not voting 16
“Not voting” is a recorded non-vote, not a reason for the absence. Parties come from public rosters; how we count.