Iowa SenateHF 639
Relating to hazardous liquid pipelines, including common carrier requirements, proceedings under the Iowa utilities commission, including commission member attendance at hearings and informational meetings, including allowing certain persons to intervene in such proceedings, including sanctions on intervenors in contested cases, and permit, permit renewal, and operation limitations, and including effective date and applicability provisions
Failed 22–28Crossed party lines
Question before the chamber: Shall amendment S–3165 to amendment S–3064 be adopted?
Amends the bill to set rules for permits for electric power plants, transmission lines, and pipelines, including commissioners attending hearings, objection filing, operator liability for drainage tile and crop damage, and farmland restoration standards. (AI-written)
The tally
Yes 22 · No 28 · Not voting 0
Bar: green = yes, brown = no, striped = not voting.
| Party | Yes | No | Not voting |
|---|---|---|---|
| Democrats | 0 | 16 | 0 |
| Republicans | 22 | 12 | 0 |
Most Democrats voted no; most Republicans voted yes. 12 members voted against their party’s majority.
Voted against their party’s majority
- Cherielynn WestrichR13No
- Dave RowleyR5No
- Dave SiresR38No
- Dennis GuthR28No
- Doug CampbellR30No
- Jeff TaylorR2No
- Kevin AlonsR7No
- Lynn EvansR3No
- Mark LofgrenR48No
- Mike PikeR20No
- Sandy SalmonR29No
- Former memberRNo
The full roll (50)
Yes 22
- Adrian DickeyR44
- Amy SinclairR12
- Annette SweeneyR27
- Carrie KoelkerR33
- Charlie McClintockR42
- Dan DawsonR10
- Dan ZumbachR34
- Dawn DriscollR46
- Jack WhitverR23
- Jason SchultzR6
- Jeff ReichmanR50
- Jesse GreenR24
- Kara WarmeR26
- Ken RozenboomR19
- Kerry GruenhagenR41
- Mark CostelloR8
- Mike BousselotR21
- Mike KlimeshR32
- Scott WebsterR47
- Tim KraayenbrinkR4
- Tom ShipleyR9
- Former memberR
No 28
- Art StaedD40
- Bill DotzlerD31
- Cherielynn WestrichR13
- Cindy WincklerD49
- Dave RowleyR5
- Dave SiresR38
- Dennis GuthR28
- Doug CampbellR30
- Herman QuirmbachD25
- Izaah KnoxD17
- Janet PetersenD18
- Janice WeinerD45
- Jeff TaylorR2
- Kevin AlonsR7
- Liz BennettD39
- Lynn EvansR3
- Mark LofgrenR48
- Matt BlakeD22
- Mike PikeR20
- Mike ZimmerD35
- Molly DonahueD37
- Sandy SalmonR29
- Sarah GarriottD14
- Tom TownsendD36
- Tony BisignanoD15
- Zach WahlsD43
- Former memberR
- Former memberD
“Not voting” is a recorded non-vote, not a reason for the absence. Parties come from public rosters; how we count.